Director Abby Stine is pleased to announce the cast of Pick Your Poison, opening in November 2025. Thank you to everyone who auditioned. We are grateful to you for sharing your time and talent with us. There are a lot of variables in casting, and if you didn’t happen to be perfect for this show, you may be perfect for something else this season. We hope to see everyone again!

Alice Jennings: Jessie Rhoades
Fifi Francois: Kaleigh White
Lord Earnest Crawford: William Marceau IV
Dr. Merlin Hayes: Aaron Stine
Octavia Osborne: Kelly Perrett
Clayton Asbury: Vinnie Sheehan-Kohler
Sir Nicholas Blackburn: Aaron Butler
Hector Perrot: Adam Leute